Tuesday, 19 February 2008

sir david kings effort to bring science



Sir David King's effort to bring science into UK nuclear discussions

I ran across an article published on Sunday 13 January 2007 by Times

Online titled I pushed Blair's nuclear button that gives some

background on high level discussions leading up to the recent decision

by the UK government to include nuclear power as a significant part of

its future energy mix.

Here is a tantalizing quote intended to make you go visit the article

and form you own opinion.

It was 2003 and Prescott thought he and the other ministers

overseeing a new energy white paper had finally reached agreement

to rule out nuclear options and instead to recommend concentration

on renewables and energy efficiency.

"That was when I put my hand up," King said last week, "and told

him I still did not believe we could cut CO2 without nuclear power.

Nor would I pretend I had changed my mind."

King claimed that what happened next was shocking. Prescott "went

ballistic", shouting about collective responsibility and thumping

the table. "I wondered if I was going to get punched," King

recalled.

I have had similar experiences while putting my hand up in high level

meetings and saying something that conflicted with the alternative

reality assumed by a person in a power position. It is not always

comfortable to be an independent voice, especially when dealing with


No comments: